The Best Old Fashioned Ice Cream Makers of 2021

Reviewed by Rob Monster
Rob Monster

Vivamus integer non suscipit taciti etiam elis primis tempor sagittis euismod libero facilisi aptent elementum felis.

Best Old Fashioned Ice Cream Makers is reader-supported. We may earn a commission through products purchased using links on this page. Learn more about our process here

You must be looking for a vintage ice cream maker that can often serve you delicious ice creams. Well, you are in the right spot. Here, you can find the best old-fashioned ice cream makers in 2021.

If you are a fan of vintage creamy ice cream, old-fashioned ice cream makers can be your best choice. These devices possess unique features and are pretty easy to use. Many experts still suggest preferring those traditional ice cream makers over the modern ones. Well, all you need is the best device that can meet your expectations in the output. Here is how?

We have selected the top-rated and most efficient old-school ice cream maker using expert advice and broad research. You can be ensured of the best deal after going through this article. So, let’s dive in!

1. Elite Gourmet Electric Motorized Ice Cream Maker

Elite Gourmet Electric Motorized Ice Cream Maker
Our Score


  • Size & Color: 4 Quart | Pine
  • Product Dimensions: 12.13 x 12.13 x 14.57 inches
  • Weight: 3 pounds

Traditional design complemented with the advanced features makes an incredible combination. This wooden bucket ice cream maker from Elite Gourmet Store is also one such impressive combo. It comes with a vintage pineapple look, but the performance of the device is not at all standard level.

One of the best things about this ice cream maker is its powerful electric motor that delivers great consistency. You can use this for making 4 quarts of cold and creamy ice cream, sorbet, frozen yogurt, and gelato, etc.  Besides, the motor-driven paddle is quite feasible and can provide the most reliable performance.

This electric motorized Ice Cream maker can be the best choice if you are about to have a birthday party or family reunion. All these advanced features with a vintage design make it one of the best old-fashioned ice cream makers in 2021. 

  • Elegant wood pine bucket design’.
  • Powerful motor and highly-efficient.
  • Serves many applications in a cold dessert.
  • The capacity of 4 quarts is pretty impressive.
  • Not compatible with refrigeration for a long time.
  • Not exactly wooden construction.

2. Nostalgia Electric Bucket Ice Cream Maker

Nostalgia Electric Bucket Ice Cream Maker
Our Score


  • Color: Brown
  • Product Dimensions: 13 x 13 x 19.75 inches
  • Weight: 12.77 pounds

Robust performance, best-in-class design, and large capacity are the features of a perfect ice cream maker. What if you get an old-school ice cream maker with all those impeccable features? This Electric Bucket Ice cream maker from Nostalgia is all about infusing all those features in one packet.

As the name suggests, the wooden brown design gives the feel of nostalgia besides enhancing the interior look. Whether it is a modern kitchen or an old-style vintage model, this device can be an impressive addition for sure. 

Apart from the build and design, this ice cream maker possesses a high-performance electric motor. Thus, the whole operation is pretty smooth and effortless without any overheating issues. Besides, it is quite easy to handle and operate no matter which ice cream-making mode you select.

With all these features, the Nostalgia ice cream maker provides ease of cleaning and maintenance. Thus, you will not need to think twice before using it at any parties or get-together, It is a powerhouse with an old-school look.

  • The motor is pretty efficient and offers great performance.
  • Wooden design is eye-pleasing.
  • Ease of maintenance.
  • Hassle-free operation.
  • Minor freezing problems.
  • The paddle can be small for some hands.

3. Elite Gourmet EIM916 Old Fashioned Ice Cream Maker

Elite Gourmet EIM916 Old Fashioned Ice Cream Maker
Our Score


  • Color: Black
  • Product Dimensions: 15 x 12 x 21.5 inches
  • Weight: 14.27 pounds

This Old-time Ice cream maker from Elite Gourmet comes with a set of incredible features that makes it preferable. It has a 6-quart capacity using which you can make many delicious desserts including sorbet, gelato, and frozen yogurts, etc. Such a capacity is more than enough to feed everyone in a mini-gathering.

On top of this, it is quite easy to use involving only 3 steps. All you have to do is mix the ingredients, assemble the unit and start the operation. So, if you are good at mixing the right ingredients in the right amount, you are all good for a mouth-watering dessert.

One of the best features of this ice cream maker is its whisper-quiet operation. Even though it has a powerful motor to support feasible operation, it is quieter than most devices. Furthermore, you don’t need to worry about long-lasting performance due to the incredible stabilizing ring.

  • 6-quart capacity.
  • Simple 3 step process.
  • Quick operation with efficient motor.
  • Whisper-quiet operation.
  • Easy to clean.
  • One year limited warranty.
  • Large capacity but could be more durable to make a perfect ice cream maker.

How to buy the best old-fashioned ice cream maker in 2021?

An old-fashioned ice cream maker not only provides creamy ice creams but also complements the interior of your house. Besides, if you are a fan of vintage designs, those ice cream makers can suit your expectations in the best way.

But, it is a mere fact that the market is flooded with tons of options with many renowned manufacturers. The same follows for the old-fashioned ice cream maker as well. You can find unlimited varieties and thousands of options from a specific category which creates immense confusion. But, there is a shortcut to it.

There are some crucial considerable factors, using which you can crack the best deal in the old-fashioned ice cream makers. Here are those crucial factors

  • Design: Now that you are looking for an old-school ice cream maker, design plays a vital role for you. Make sure that the design suits your requirements and meets your expectations in complementing the rooms. Design is an uncompromisable factor for an old-fashioned ice cream maker in 2021.
  • Performance and efficiency: If you are going for an automatic ice cream maker, the motor plays a major role in delivering great performance. But, it is also one of the major aspects of energy efficiency. So get a device with a robust and powerful motor. Similarly, if you prefer the manual type, see whether the moment is not draining your energy. The key is you should get more output with less effort.
  • Capacity: Capacity should be one of the top priorities while buying an ice cream maker. So, look for the most suitable capacity for your frequency of usage. If you often have a house party, you should probably go for a larger capacity ranging from 6 to 8 quart. 
  • Speed and ease of usage: Right after considering the capacity and efficiency, ease of usage is an important factor. You should go for a device that can deliver output faster. Similarly, ease of usage is also essential so that you can get the most out of your ice cream maker.
  • Durability: A device with all those features is futile if it won’t last long in your kitchen. So make sure to get an old-school ice cream maker that looks vintage but is highly durable. You can find wood, copper, and aluminum options in the market. Less noise is a quality of a long-lasting ice cream maker, so better to go for it.
  • Price: Old fashioned ice cream makers are sometimes affordable and sometimes pretty expensive. So, make sure to go through enough options for comparison to get the right product at the best deal.

Frequently Asked Questions

  • What is the working operation for an old-fashioned ice cream maker?

The operation differs from one model to another. But, an old-fashioned ice cream maker doesn’t mean it works with traditional principles. Most of the old-school ice cream makers right now have powerful electric motors. Besides, they come along with a ton of unique features that sometimes make modern devices look outdated.

But, if you are going for the manually operated devices, you need to look for the paddle and handle quality. The operations for those mechanical parts are sometimes tricky to judge. 

Now that you are looking for the operation, it works with a simple motor principle having a frozen bowl to place ingredients.

  • Is it good to select a manual ice cream maker?

Manual ice cream makers often provide equal performance as the automatic models. But, you need to decide whether you are ready to put your efforts into making ice cream. Generally, it takes more than 15 minutes to make a complete ice cream. Well, if you are a newbie to ice cream making, automatic ones are indeed the best option.

  • Can I find a compatible old-fashioned ice maker?

Yes, like standard ice cream makers, the old-school devices also come with different capacities. You can choose between 1.5 to 6-quart ice cream capacity in those machines. Make sure to get the most suitable device for your requirements. But, the greater the size, the longer will it take to make ice cream. So, you need to focus on motor performance too.

Finally Who is The Winner?

By now, you are familiar with every single aspect regarding an old-fashioned ice cream maker. But, make sure to consider all those factors mentioned above to get a device that meets your expectations in performance. 

Of course, the brand value and price of such products matter a lot. So, you need to be clear about whether it can provide long-lasting performance. For an instance, Elite Gourmet can be your best choice with a large capacity of 6 quarts. It also comes with advanced features like whisper quiet operation which leaps over the competition.

Leave a Comment